Wallsten on How to Evaluate Broadband Stimulus Dollars

Wallsten on How to Evaluate Broadband Stimulus Dollars

Contact: Ashley Creel
(202) 828-4405

March 24, 2009 – The recently enacted $7 billion broadband stimulus plan presents a unique opportunity to learn what kinds of broadband subsidies can make a difference, Technology Policy Institute Vice President for Research and Senior Fellow Scott Wallsten explains in a new article. We can learn whether the program funded projects that truly needed funding only by building evaluation into the grant making process itself. The broadband dollars will not be well spent if they fund broadband projects that providers are already undertaking. To be successful, the program should fund broadband projects that nobody would undertake without the subsidy. To determine whether the subsidies truly made a difference, program evaluators need to track projects and firms that do not receive funds as well as those that do. An even better approach would be to introduce some randomization into the grant-making process to facilitate comparisons between “treatment” and “control” groups. The lessons that we learn from a rigorous evaluation can then be applied to other existing and future broadband programs. Wallsten’s paper, “Measuring the Effectiveness of the Broadband Stimulus Plan,” can be found at https://techpolicyinstitute.org.

The Technology Policy Institute

The Technology Policy Institute is a research and educational organization that focuses on the economics of innovation, technological change, and related regulation in the United States and around the world. More information is available at https://techpolicyinstitute.org/

Website |  + posts

Share This Article

View More Publications by

Recommended Reads

Regulating the Internet

The FCC’s New Wireless Competition Report: The Right Way to Look at the Industry

The FCC Tries to Find Its Way

Explore More Topics

Antitrust and Competition 182
Artificial Intelligence 34
Big Data 21
Blockchain 29
Broadband 387
China 2
Content Moderation 15
Economics and Methods 37
Economics of Digitization 15
Evidence-Based Policy 18
Free Speech 20
Infrastructure 1
Innovation 2
Intellectual Property 56
Miscellaneous 334
Privacy and Security 137
Regulation 12
Trade 2
Uncategorized 4

Related Articles

TPI Comments Warn FCC Space Licensing Reforms May Worsen Congestion Without Market Mechanisms

TPI Proposes Market-Based Auction to Consolidate Rural Carriers and Reduce USF Costs

Comments filed with the Federal Communications Commission in the Matter of Space Modernization for the 21st Century

Announcing the 2026 TPI Winter Spectrum Series 

The Voluntary IP Service Transition Auction (VISTA)

Advanced Spectrum Policy Primer

BEAD’s Bidding for Broadband: Why Williamson’s 1976 Analysis Still Matters

New BEAD Rules Enable Efficient Spending But Make it Pointless to Try

Sign Up for Updates

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.