Peering or End of the Internet as we know It?

Peering or End of the Internet as we know It?

One of the top tech stories in the headlines of late is the dispute between Comcast and Level 3.  For those of you who were ignoring mass media last week: the dispute is over traffic handling agreements, apparently spurred by the announcement of a deal between Level 3 and Netflix to carry the latter’s streaming video.

Depending on who you listen to, the Comcast / Level 3 dispute is either a simple peering disagreement blown out of proportion or a gross violation of network neutrality principles and the beginning of the “tiered internet.”  So, where does the truth lie?  According to TPI’s Scott Wallsten, probably somewhere in the middle.   

Scott shared his views on the Comcast / Level 3 dispute on the EEEI Spectrum podcast, “This Week in Technology,” hosted by Steven Cherry.  In short, he identified the conflict as a dispute over who will pay for the increased cost resulting from the video traffic.  He also explained that there is a possibility of incentives to erect barriers to competition in such a deal but that the DOJ can adequately deal with such concerns through antitrust enforcement.  Scott also discusses his predictions on the outcome of the dispute and the future of the video delivery business.  The podcast can be found here.

Amy V. Smorodin was Vice President of Communications and External Relations at the Technology Policy Institute. Prior to joining TPI, she was Vice President of Communications at The Progress & Freedom Foundation. Smorodin also served as a public policy communications specialist at the Computing Technology Industry Association (CompTIA), a global tech industry association. She began her media and public relations career at the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children, where she acted as liaison between families, law enforcement, and the media. Smorodin attended American University in Washington, DC.

Share This Article

View More Publications by

Recommended Reads

TPI Comments Warn FCC Space Licensing Reforms May Worsen Congestion Without Market Mechanisms

Press Releases

TPI Proposes Market-Based Auction to Consolidate Rural Carriers and Reduce USF Costs

Press Releases

Comments filed with the Federal Communications Commission in the Matter of Space Modernization for the 21st Century

Testimony and Filings

Explore More Topics

Antitrust and Competition 182
Artificial Intelligence 38
Big Data 21
Blockchain 29
Broadband 387
China 2
Content Moderation 15
Economics and Methods 37
Economics of Digitization 15
Evidence-Based Policy 18
Free Speech 20
Infrastructure 1
Innovation 2
Intellectual Property 56
Miscellaneous 334
Privacy and Security 137
Regulation 15
Trade 2
Uncategorized 4

Related Articles

TPI Fireside Chat with NTIA Administrator Arielle Roth Recap

Preparing for WRC-27 Panel Recap

Why Policy Experiments Never End: Constituencies Form Faster Than Evidence

CBRS in 2026: What Have We Learned? Panel Recap

Ambassador Steve Lang on WRC-27 and International Telecom Diplomacy

The Direct-to-Device Era: Panel Recap

2026 TPI Winter Spectrum Series: The Direct to Device Era

TPI Comments Warn FCC Space Licensing Reforms May Worsen Congestion Without Market Mechanisms

Sign Up for Updates

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.